Quick Comparison — All 8 Products
Every product ranked by real Amazon reviews, price and results
| # | Product | Price | Reviews | Stars | Type |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Millennium Black Bronzing Lotion | $29.95 | 31,754 | ★★★★☆ (4.5) | Bronzing lotion |
| 2 | Beauty by Earth Self Tanner | $35.99 | 25,566 | ★★★★☆ (4.3) | Self-tanner lotion |
| 3 | St. Tropez Self Tan Express Mousse | $46.00 | 15,299 | ★★★★☆ (4.5) | Express self-tanner |
| 4 | Bondi Sands Gradual Tanning Milk | $19.99 | 14,382 | ★★★★☆ (4.2) | Gradual tanner |
| 5 | Carroten Tan Express Gel | $29.99 | 9,566 | ★★★★☆ (4.3) | Gel accelerator |
| 6 | Australian Gold Dark Tanning Spray | $8.99 | 6,124 | ★★★★☆ (4.5) | Spray accelerator |
| 7 | Maui Babe Browning Lotion | $14.99 | 7,471 | ★★★★☆ (4.4) | Browning lotion |
| 8 | Hawaiian Tropic Dark Tanning Oil | $20.98 | 5,240 | ★★★★★ (4.8) | Tanning oil |
The 8 Best Tanning Lotions & Glow Oils Reviewed
Carroten Tan Express Intensive Tanning Gel
A Greek cult classic with over 9,500 reviews — Carroten is the undisputed king of tanning gels. Made with carrot oil, coconut oil and vitamin E, this non-greasy formula accelerates your natural tan outdoors and is water-resistant so it stays on at the beach or pool. With it's a proven favourite, it's Amazon's most popular tanning gel for good reason — it actually works.
✦ Pros
- 9,566 reviews
- Non-greasy, water-resistant
- Natural carrot & coconut oil
- Made in Greece 🇬🇷
- 2,400+ bought last month
✦ Cons
- Outdoor use only — needs sun
- Not a self-tanner (no DHA)
Hawaii's #1 tanning secret with 7,471 reviews. Made with Kona coffee extract, kukui nut oil and aloe vera — Maui Babe's browning lotion delivers that rich, deep island tan that looks like you've spent two weeks in the Pacific. It's lightweight, non-greasy and completely natural. Once you try it, you'll never go back to any other tanning lotion.
✦ Pros
- 7,471 verified reviews
- Kona coffee + kukui nut formula
- Lightweight and non-greasy
- All-natural ingredients
✦ Cons
- Coffee scent divides opinion
- Outdoor use only
Hawaiian Tropic Dark Tanning Oil SPF 6
The classic tanning oil that's been delivering golden results for decades — and at under $13 it's the best value on this entire list. Hawaiian Tropic's coconut and papaya formula deeply moisturises your skin while amplifying your tan, leaving you with a rich golden colour and that iconic tropical scent. Over 5,200 reviews confirm it's one of the most beloved tanning oils of all time.
✦ Pros
- Twin pack available — great value
- 5,240 reviews
- Coconut & papaya formula
- Deep moisturising effect
✦ Cons
- Low SPF 6 — reapply often
- Outdoor use only
St. Tropez Self Tan Express Bronzing Mousse
The salon favourite that delivers a flawless, streak-free tan in as little as 1–3 hours. St. Tropez's express mousse lets you control your depth — leave it on 1 hr for light, 2 hrs for medium, 3 hrs for dark. Vegan, natural and cruelty-free. 6.7 fl oz. The closest thing to a professional spray tan at home — and the reviews prove it.
✦ Pros
- Results in just 1–3 hours
- 15,299 reviews
- Control your shade depth
- Vegan, natural & cruelty-free
- Works without sun
✦ Cons
- Most expensive on this list
- Best with a tanning mitt
Australian Gold Dark Tanning Accelerator Spray
Australian Gold's dark tanning spray is packed with natural bronzers and moisturisers that help you develop a rich golden tan faster outdoors. The oxybenzone-free formula is lightweight and smells like a Queensland beach holiday. At under $20 with over 6,100 reviews, it's one of the best affordable tan accelerators on Amazon — particularly popular with those who prefer a spray format.
✦ Pros
- Oxybenzone-free formula
- Easy spray application
- 6,124 verified reviews
- Under $20
✦ Cons
- Spray nozzle can be inconsistent
- Outdoor use only
Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Tanning Lotion
Clean organic formula with aloe and coconut oil. Streak-free, no orange tones. USA-made for a natural medium-to-dark golden glow. Vegan and cruelty-free. This self-tanner works without sun exposure, making it perfect for year-round use. 25,566 reviews confirm it delivers on every promise — a genuinely natural-looking golden glow without any of the usual self-tanner pitfalls.
✦ Pros
- No orange tones — golden finish
- Organic, clean ingredients
- Vegan & cruelty-free
- USA-made formula
- Works without sun
✦ Cons
- Takes 4–8 hrs to fully develop
- Pricier than drugstore options
Bondi Sands Everyday Gradual Tanning Milk
Buildable daily glow for pale to medium skin. Hydrating cocoa butter formula. Zero orange risk — just a subtle sun-kissed glow that grows with every use. Apply it like a daily moisturiser and build your colour gradually over 3–5 days. For beginners or anyone nervous about going too dark, this is the safest and most forgiving formula on the list.
✦ Pros
- Zero orange risk
- Cocoa butter — deeply hydrating
- Buildable over 3–5 days
- 14,382 verified reviews
- Works without sun
✦ Cons
- Takes days to build visible colour
- Won't give a deep dark tan
Millennium Tanning Black Bronzing Lotion
For those who want serious dark colour — Millennium's Black formula is in a league of its own. The silicone-enhancing formula feels incredibly silky, the immediate bronzer gives instant visible colour, and the real tan develops underneath. Works both indoors and outdoors making it perfect for building a base tan before a holiday. If you want the darkest possible result, this is your pick.
✦ Pros
- Works indoors + outdoors
- Immediate bronzer effect
- Silicone-enhancing formula
- Deepest colour on this list
✦ Cons
- Too intense for beginners
- Strong bronzer scent
How to Choose the Right Formula
The right tanning lotion or glow oil depends on your skin tone, lifestyle and how quickly you want results
Outdoor vs Indoor Use
Tan accelerators like Carroten, Maui Babe, Hawaiian Tropic and Australian Gold require actual sunlight — they amplify your natural tan outdoors. Self-tanners like St. Tropez, Beauty by Earth and Bondi Sands work without any sun exposure.
Match Your Skin Tone
Fair skin? Start with Bondi Sands Gradual Milk to build colour slowly with zero risk. Medium skin? Any formula works well. Want the deepest result? Millennium Black is built for serious colour.
How Fast Do You Need Results?
Event tonight? St. Tropez Express delivers in 1–3 hours. No rush? Bondi Sands Gradual builds beautifully over 3–5 days with zero risk of streaks or going too dark too fast.
Check the Ingredients
For a clean formula, Beauty by Earth uses organic aloe and coconut oil. For all-natural outdoor formulas, Maui Babe uses Kona coffee and kukui nut. For budget value, Hawaiian Tropic uses coconut and papaya.
Always Add Separate SPF
Tanning oils and accelerators do not protect against UV damage. Always apply a separate SPF product before going outdoors, especially on your face. Reapply every 2 hours when in the sun.
Moisturise Daily
Well-moisturised skin tans more evenly and holds colour longer. Apply your tanning product to already-moisturised skin for the best results and smoothest application — and top up with moisturiser daily to extend your glow.
Frequently Asked Questions
Our Final Verdict ☀️
For most people, Carroten Tan Express Gel is the undisputed #1 — 14,035 reviews don't lie and the results speak for themselves. On a tight budget? Hawaiian Tropic at under $13 delivers incredible value. Need results fast without sun? St. Tropez Express delivers a flawless tan in just 1–3 hours. Want the darkest possible colour? Millennium Black is in a league of its own. Whatever you choose — always add a separate SPF, moisturise daily, and enjoy your best golden summer yet. ☀️
Want More Affordable Luxury Finds?
We drop new curated picks every week — tanning, skincare, dresses and more.
Read More Guides →